Italy’s Data Protection Authority has fined Meta Platforms Ireland Limited €805 million over a Facebook feature for Android devices that accesses photos, videos and related metadata stored in users’ phone galleries. Announced on November 14, 2026, the decision concerns a feature called “Get suggestions from gallery when browsing Facebook”, which recommends images and videos from a user’s device as potential material for social media posts. The Garante found that the feature was enabled by default and that Facebook accessed gallery content belonging to users in Italy without obtaining specific, informed consent or adequately explaining the purpose of the access. The regulator said the feature had been available since 2023 and that its investigation began in July 2025 following a complaint from the Centro Tutela Consumatori Utenti, a consumer protection organisation based in Bolzano. The authority’s technical assessment found that Facebook used a single device permission covering multiple app functions with different purposes. A general notice asking users to enable additional features did not clearly explain that granting the permission would also activate gallery suggestions. According to the regulator, this arrangement did not provide users with sufficient information to make a clear decision about allowing the feature to access their personal photo and video collections. The authority said the relevant permission could allow the application to read the device’s gallery, generally on an ongoing basis, without users or the regulator being able to establish precisely which information was used.
The Garante determined that the practice violated Article 122 of Italy’s Privacy Code, which implements the European Union’s ePrivacy rules into national law. The provision protects information stored on users’ devices and requires free and informed consent before applications access that information. The regulator said the requirement applies regardless of whether the information is subsequently transmitted elsewhere or whether a user can demonstrate direct harm. Under its order, Meta must make the gallery-suggestion feature inactive by default for Italian Facebook users on Android devices and introduce a separate, specific consent request before enabling it. The company must clearly explain the feature’s purpose, disclose that it requires access to the phone’s gallery and provide information about how users can disable it or withdraw permission. These requirements also apply to people who have already granted Facebook gallery access through their device settings. The authority further instructed Meta to report the steps it has initiated within 30 days and provide information about the measures implemented within 90 days. The 60-day compliance period applies to the required changes to the feature and consent process. If the company does not meet the deadline, the feature cannot be activated for users who have not provided valid consent. In determining the penalty, the regulator considered the number of people potentially affected, estimated at approximately 20 million Android users in Italy, the duration of the issue and a previous decision involving the company in 2019. It also cited limited cooperation during the investigation, while taking into account changes Meta introduced after the initial complaint.
Meta has said it intends to appeal the decision and considers the €805 million penalty disproportionate. In a statement reported by Reuters, a company spokesperson said users must grant permission through their device before the feature can operate and can change that permission through their phone settings. Meta also described the functionality as a feature designed to help people share photos and videos on Facebook. The regulator, however, found that the general permission request did not adequately explain the separate gallery-suggestion purpose or provide users with a sufficiently specific choice. The investigation did not examine whether photos or videos accessed through this feature were used to train artificial intelligence models. The Garante stated that Meta denies such use and that the matter was outside the scope of the proceedings. The authority has reserved the possibility of conducting a separate assessment of another feature introduced in 2026 that allows content from users’ galleries to be processed in the cloud. The company had also challenged the Italian authority’s competence to handle the case, arguing that the matter should fall under the responsibility of Ireland’s data protection regulator. The Garante rejected that position, explaining that the ePrivacy framework does not provide for the one-stop-shop mechanism that applies to certain other data protection matters. The decision therefore addresses the specific gallery-suggestion functionality and the way consent was requested from Italian Android users, rather than establishing a finding about every Facebook feature or all Meta services.
The case highlights the importance of clear permission requests when mobile applications seek access to personal information stored on smartphones. A single device-level permission may cover several functions, but the regulator’s decision makes clear that users must understand the particular purpose for which their information is accessed. The Centro Tutela Consumatori Utenti, whose complaint prompted the investigation, had previously published guidance on Facebook’s gallery settings on July 11, 2025. Its advice encouraged users to review the application’s settings and check the permissions granted through their Android devices. The Garante’s ruling also distinguishes the gallery-suggestion feature from the separate question of whether content is used for artificial intelligence development, which was not examined in this investigation. The authority said the breach remained ongoing for users who had not updated the application and for those who had already granted the relevant system permission, which contributed to its assessment of the case. The €805 million penalty amounts to approximately 0.47% of Meta’s global turnover, according to the regulator. Meta’s planned appeal means the company disputes the findings and the level of the penalty, while the authority’s order sets out the changes it expects the company to make within the specified deadlines. The decision places particular emphasis on separate consent, clear explanations and default privacy settings for applications that access personal photos, videos and other information stored on mobile devices.
Follow the SPIN IDG WhatsApp Channel for updates across the Smart Pakistan Insights Network covering all of Pakistan’s technology ecosystem.





